An email from Jimmy Leas
Folks,
A new stockholder resolution on Pension and Retirement Medical was
recently submitted to IBM for a vote at the next IBM stockholder
meeting. Last year over 300 IBM employees and retirees and a number
of other IBM stockholders signed on as official cosponsors of a
similar resolution. Please add your name as a cosponsor of the 2002
resolution. You can use the form at the bottom of this email to sign
on as an official cosponsor. Simply press "forward", then fill in the
form and email to the IBM Corporate Secretary and to me. Thanks very
much. Here are the two addresses:
IBM Corporate Secretary,
James M. Leas
Jimmy
Please read and cosponsor by filling out the form found at the bottom
of this page. Please circulate to friends and colleages. This
resolution and a sign on form are also on the web at
http://www.geocities.com/btvpension/Resolution2002.htm
2002 IBM Stockholder Resolution on Pension and Retirement Medical
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Resolved: shareholders request that the Board adopt the following
policy:
Age discrimination in retirement policies will be ended by allowing
all employees, regardless of age, to receive the same long-promised
retirement medical insurance and pension choice as employees who were
within five years of retirement in 1999.
In 1999 IBM announced new cash balance pension and retirement medical
insurance plans. These plans effectively revoked long-promised plans
for many employees.
IBM divided employees into three permanent groups based on their age
on June 30, 1999. Employees older than 50 with 15 years of service
kept the old medical and could choose between the old and new pension
plans. Employees older than 40 with ten years of service could also
chose between pension plans but were forced into the new retirement
medical. Employees younger than 40 and older employees who did not
have at least 10 years of service were forced into both the new
medical and the new cash balance pension. IBM thus broke its highly
touted and unqualified promise not to discriminate based on age.
According to BNA's March 7, 2001 Employment Discrimination
Report, "the Internal Revenue Service has put a hold on the agency's
approval of new cash balance plans pending an examination of the age
discrimination implications of such arrangements. Since 1999, EEOC
has joined with the Treasury Department and the Labor Department in a
coordinated review to decide whether cash balance plans can be
squared with federal age discrimination laws." Whatever the outcomes,
IBM's age discrimination will have serious consequences for
effected
employees.
IBM openly acknowledged that the average employee would lose 20% of
retirement pay under the cash balance plan. The Wall Street Journal
estimated losses as high as 50%.
IBM also acknowledged to some employees that their new individual
medical insurance accounts would probably run out of money as they
approach old age. Revoking lifetime medical insurance is especially a
problem for lower-paid workers.
IBM management argues that the cash balance plan is better to attract
younger workers. If so, why are younger workers the only age group
not offered a choice of pension plans?
Conversion to cash balance pension plan failed to benefit the
company. IBM declared that the $200 million "saved" would fund stock
options for executives and other targeted employees. However,
the "savings" actually accumulate as a surplus in the separate
pension trust fund. Money cannot be transferred to IBM from this
fund. Moreover IBM has paid nothing for pensions for the last six
years because the $70 billion pension trust fund has a large surplus
and earns more in interest than it pays out to retirees.
In short, the cash balance plan conversion brought no money into the
company, saved no money, had no apparent advantages for stockholders,
opened the company to investigation and possible suits for age
discrimination, generated negative publicity, and may well have had
material adverse effects on the morale of company employees.
Therefore, IBM should end age discrimination in retirement policies.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Please (1) press the key to "forward" this email or cut and paste the
following form into a new e-mail, (2) fill it in and (3) email to the
IBM corporate secretary and to me:
IBM Corporate Secretary,
James M. Leas
You can also print and mail in hard copy.
Please also circulate to friends and colleagues.
Deadline: To be listed as a cosponsor IBM must receive before
November 12 at 5pm
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Office of the Secretary
International Business Machines Corporation
New Orchard Road
Armonk, NY 10504
corpsecy@us.ibm.com
Sir:
Please add my name as a cosponsor of the 2002 IBM Stockholder
Proposal on Pension and Retirement Medical
submitted by James M. Leas.
Full Name___________________________________________________
Home Street Address_______________________________________
Home State and Zip _______________________________________
Home email address_______________________________________
I own at least one share of IBM stock Yes or No? ___________
If yes how many shares _______________
Please provide the following to help IBM identify you as an owner of
shares
If you know the FCTC/Equiserve Account # _____________________
and/or name of broker (including TDSP) ___________________________
I am an IBM employee Yes or No? ___________
I am an IBM retiree Yes or No? ___________
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
There is now a
Second resolution for the Shareholders meeting.
|